【贺卫方质疑人大要求香港特首“爱国爱港”不合基本法】
22日上午，全国人大常委会副秘书长李飞在“香港社会各界人士座谈会”发表讲话时指出，中央的立场是坚定而明确的，香港行政长官普选办法必须符合香港基本法和全国人大常委会的决定，行政长官必须由“爱国爱港”人士担任。对此，23日，中国著名法学学者、北京大学法学教授贺卫方发微博指出，香港基本法并没有要求香港特首“爱国爱港”的规定，因此中国人大提出的该项要求是否符合基本法存疑。
北大教授贺卫方（资料图）
微博截图
全国人大常委会将于未来一周举行会议，讨论香港特区政府提交的政制改革报告，其中最受关注的是有关2017年香港特首选举的办法。近来，北京中央政府及香港特区官员均表示，香港特首候选人必须由提名委员会提名，以确保未来的香港特首“爱国爱港”。
8月23日贺卫方在其新浪个人微博上发文说：“依据基本法，香港特首除年龄国籍规定外，只有47条规定的‘廉洁奉公，尽忠职守’，爱国爱港并不在其中，人大提出此要求合否基本法存疑。”贺卫方还在微博留言中表示：“爱国爱港标准何在，谁界定？太难。”截至观察者网发稿，贺卫方的此条微博已经被转发1000余次，评论1000多条。
【本网站解析】（原载于凤凰网）
贺卫方先生的观点缺乏辩证逻辑，也不够深刻，该预知的问题没有发现，不该望文生义的却流于肤浅。
1、基本法规定的“尽忠职守”，职守就是爱护香港，而香港已是中国的组成部分，因而，从逻辑上讲，就应该对中国也尽忠，即爱国。
2、基本法是全国人大制定的，全国人大有权做相应的补充，甚至改变，何况，要求特首爱国是其法律逻辑要求，当然于法有据。
3、问题只是在于：当还是特首候选人时，尚未有实际行使特首职权，并不能确定其是否会“尽忠职守”，而以候选人是否“爱国”的标准难以量化，除非他以实际行动或明确或公开表示叛国、独立、阻断香港与内地的联系或否定中央依法领导等，不过，对此，人民自有公论，香港选民有权以自己的选票来作出评判。
4、问题还在于，当香港选民的投票不同意提名委员会的候选人，或者香港人民选举出的特首，中央又以“不爱国爱港”等原因不批准任命时，就会导致反复、纠结、甚至——。
对此，如何化解？敬请查看www.alldemocracybigfamily.com或在google直接输入“全民主共产主义大家庭”，就一切疑难迎刃而解—–也欢迎贺卫方先生与我辩论，如果我输了，决不再上网发文！
Comments 42
Your articles are for when it absolutely, positively, needs to be understood overnight.
Gracias Javier por la difusión del proyecto.SerÃa muy gratificante contar con la participación de alumnos de 2º Ciclo. Los alumnos y alumnas de 1er ciclo ya están comenzando a utilizar las herramientas TIC necesarias para su participación en clase. De hecho, ya han aportado su granito de arena con unas cuantas participaciones a través de poemas recitados ejemplarmente. Esperamos más contribuciones, especialmente relacionadas con las CCSS, con quien la Literatura tiene una estrechÃsima relación.
It’s about time someone wrote about this.
gelsin tüm afk oyuncuları ya dizi öyle reytik yapıyor öyle güzel geçen seneyi çok özlüyorum cumayı sabırsızlıkla bekliyordum şimdi tv izlemiyorum hazal gelsin )
the social justice stuff has become commonplace among younger liberal clergyit essentially means transforming religion into liberalism, which means secularizing religion
Last one to utilize this is a rotten egg!
Episode 7 !! All in one day ?? Yea ! You like it !How does it feel to be ‘turned’.Yea… M is a Moony. M likes Sexy Vamp Mick !I am happy !Love ya all !Laurie
Yes it had to with the lyrics but he was on a family network with kids watching that. He knew that. If he had been on MTV that would of been fine but he wasn’t. I certainly didn’t want to see him grabbing people’s crotches. it was horrible and disgusting and very disturbing to watch.
Sugar and fat should be dissonant to our psyche. Gracious, what could possibly be so “siren” about the awful things!? We’re a curious lot… And I think 3′s a win as well. though sharing your plan – that’s a bold move!
That kind of thinking shows you’re on top of your game
disse:esses fpd’s naum tem vergonha na kara e colokaram as minhas 2 preferidas no paredao… ¬¬¹²³ ana e josi merecian o 1º e 2º lugar no BBB9 +… ja que aconteceu isso… ana rulez \\o
Bill Gates' fault. Before MS Windows, it took a little intelligence to get on the internet. Now, any retard can get online and spew forth lies, name-calling, hate and mindless dribble as exemplified by Ms. Anonymous' hate words about the Tea Party Americans. We use to be a great, God fearing country. Not anymore.
You get a lot of respect from me for writing these helpful articles.
amo a mika soy una fan de el no me iamporta lo que pase yo lo seguire amando !!!!!aun asi si es gay o no… el es mi artista favorito y siempre lo sera y siempre lo segure amando[]
That’s really thinking at an impressive level
Love the portrait. Associating Osiris with Death, of course, makes perfect sense. I’ll be doing the same in my world. Interestingly, I’ve read stories where death and time were strongly associated. And I can see the connection with the ocean and death. Both are very deep and mysterious.
Ã…h, det här mÃ¥ste jag ju spela! Tyävrr har jag nÃ¥gra levlar kvar innan jag vÃ¥gar ta mig an det…Sen lockar ju Dragon Age och MW2 rackans mycket :(Bra skrivet tycker jag, precis sÃ¥nt man vill veta innan man bestämmer för sig om det är värt att handlas eller inte.
Rodrigo:Notable reseña, me veo en el estadio El Morro,un dÃa sábado de los ´80, junto a mi padre y con la tronadura “del cañoncito”. El Loco era re entrete, una lástima su partida, no lo sabÃa.Para los que no conocieron a “Naval”, agregar que por este club pasaron y los và jugar: Juan Soto, Jorge “Mortero” Aravena,Candonga Carreño, Arturo Jauregui, Rambo RamÃrez, entre otros, para no dejar a nadie abajo.También, quisiera recordar, no lo và porque solo tenÃa 2 años, que “O Rei Pelé”, jugó en El Morro el ´63.
Und schon ist der Artikel auf der Startseite von Spiegel Online ganz nach unten gerutscht. Ich wette, in wenigen Stunden oder sogar schon Minuten ist er auf der Startseite gar nicht mehr zu sehen.Ich würde das nicht schreiben oder für bedenklich halten, wenn ich es nicht schon etliche Male beobachtet hätte. Die ganze große Presse ist für mich nur noch eine Lachnummer.
admin spune:Vivamus id massa non arcu adipiscing mollis. Aliquam vitae mauris odio. Morbi magna est, egestas et suscipit at, viverra sed erat.
A minute saved is a minute earned, and this saved hours!
Je n’avoue connaitre de lui que ses photos mais j’en suis fan. En tout cas il est temps que je remonte ? Paris je loupe encore une chouette expo…
Why does this have to be the ONLY reliable source? Oh well, gj!
Sir Philip Green’s report that was published last week provides an insight in to some of the areas of government where significant cost can be saved, namely more effective procurement and supplier contract management.
Apparently this is what the esteemed Willis was talkin’ ’bout.
I know this garden/daylily farm. Fabulous place. I spent an exciting afternoon with the owner who toured me all over in my quest for just the right daylily for a special spot and time of bloom. Am sorry you missed her and missed sharing her love of her land and daylilys.
Cool…Hello there, just became alert to your blog through Google, and found that it is truly informative. I’m gonna watch out for brussels. I will be grateful if you continue this in future. Lots of people will be benefited from your writing. Cheers!…
Your Purrime Ministertes are back in da house.Today we gotted even more prezzies. And tomorrow…oh please, come back tomorrow. You not shall believe green eyes in nine lives! We won’t be able to sleep! Sooooo eggzited! Tomorrow’s prezzie shall be ameowzing!
Yo, good lookin out! Gonna make it work now.
Thanks for introducing a little rationality into this debate.
Thanks, Alex. And all our ‘facts’ (I’m required to put the quotes there for certain legal reasons you’d no doubt find boring, but just go ahead and pretend they’re not there) are so thoroughly vetted that there’s no reason whatsoever to check. Seriously, you don’t want to do that.
That’s a wise answer to a tricky question
That’s a posting full of insight!
JD: This is intentionally NOT a comprehensive background. The facts in it are selected to support the upcoming policy options, i.e. give relevant background info for each one. An options paper cant list all a country’s history, that’s just not practical.
Talán azért érzed Ãgy, mert papÃrusz szÃn az alapszÃn és betűszÃnűek (arany és szürke) a kiegészÃtÅ‘ szÃnek.Mindenesetre igazán lehetne akár az én fürdÅ‘m is, de ahhoz el kéne válnom, és egyedül vagy egy nÅ‘vel kellene együtt élnem.
transferred the list in its entirety, please keep in mind that only those submissions that fulfill both requirements will be included in the draw. Thank you for taking part and good luck my
amo la cultura giapponese@ Gala: interessante….dicci comunque dove si trova…magari nn è tanto lontano@ viola: diciamo zona trastevere, san paolo, eur…troppo vasta?PS: perchè dovremmo evitarle??@ kira: speriamo prevalga quella che ti ispira :em32: @ kermittina: che fortunata :em28:Ok…grazie per le dritte :em21:
Hoi,Ik maak 1 grote uil en 1 kleine uil voor iemand die ik heb getrokken. Hij wordt echt super leuk. Ik heb hem i.p.v katoen handdoeken gebruikt bij de action.
Wise advice. It’s a constant struggle to maintain a clear distinction between need and want. The advertisers are telling us that we need need need. We need a constant reminder to ourselves that we have have have in abundance.
A minute saved is a minute earned, and this saved hours!
the following.1. à ®¤à ®©à ®¿à ®¯à ®¾à ®°à ¯ à ®•à ®²à ¯Âà ®µà ®¿ à ®¨à ®¿à ®±à ¯Âà ®µà ®©à ®™à ¯Âà ®•à ®³à ®¿à ®©à ¯ à ®…à ®¨à ®¿à ®¯à ®¾à ®¯ à ®•à ®²à ¯Âà ®µà ®¿à ®•à ¯Âà ®•à ¯Šà ®³à ¯Âà ®³à ¯ˆà ®•à ¯Âà ®•à ¯ à ®Žà ®¤à ®¿à ®°à ®¾à ®•à ®ªà ¯ à ®ªà ¯‹à ®°à ®¾à ®Ÿà ¯Âà ®µà ®¤à ¯Â. 2. à ®…à ®°à ®šà ¯Âà ®ªà ¯ à ®ªà ®³à ¯Âà ®³à ®¿à ®•à ®³à ¯ˆ à ®¤à ®°à ®®à ®¾à ®• à ®¨à ®Ÿà ®¤à ¯Âà ®¤à ®ªà ¯ à ®ªà ¯‹à ®°à ®¾à ®Ÿà ¯Âà ®µà ®¤à ¯Â. à ®‡à ®µà ¯ˆ à ®‡à ®°à ®£à ¯Âà ®Ÿà ¯Âà ®®à ¯ à ®¨à ®Ÿà ¯ˆà ®®à ¯Âà ®±à ¯ˆ à ®šà ®¾à ®¤à ¯Âà ®¤à ®¿à ®¯à ®®à ®¾à ®©à ®¤à ¯‡.Don’t you know that this is simple and why can’t surya and sasi understand this and fight for this. if they do next day CBI will be on their door to check their accounts, so they don’t fight against issues instead do cheep publicity.
the more color the merrier i say!I like your colors!The coat is beautiful- it would be just right for here, so cold these days!Nice that your little one received a package from a fellow bloggerTake care CursiteAriane xxx